Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

How Long Do Home Insurance Claims Stay on Record?

January 27th, 2025

2 min read

By Daniel J. Middleton

How long do home insurance claims stay on record

As a Central New York homeowner, deciding whether to file an insurance claim can feel overwhelming. Many homeowners wonder about how long a claim might affect rates or if it could limit future coverage options.

Without clear information about the long-term impact of claims, homeowners may face decisions that could affect insurance choices for years to come.

At the Horan insurance agency, we work with multiple carriers to share information about how claims history may influence coverage. As an independent agency serving Central New York, we aim to provide insights about these relationships while exploring available insurance options.

In this article, we'll explore how long claims typically stay on record, what multiple claims might mean for coverage, and considerations that may help inform decisions about filing claims.

Start of ice dam on a rustic CNY cabinHow Claims History May Affect Central New York Home Insurance Options

A homeowner's insurance claim typically remains on record for five years. During this time, insurance carriers consider these claims when evaluating applications and determining rates.

While most carriers increase premiums for homeowners with claims in their history, a small number of companies may not raise rates for a single claim. However, many carriers might limit coverage availability for multiple claims.

For Central New York homeowners dealing with seasonal challenges like ice dams or wind damage, this five-year timeframe often becomes an important consideration. A claim filed this winter could influence insurance options through several more seasons of weather-related events.

What Multiple Claims May Mean for Coverage Availability

While a single claim within five years might lead to rate adjustments, filing multiple claims often creates additional considerations. Many carriers may become hesitant to provide coverage when reviewing two or more claims within a five-year period. This situation could result in fewer options and different premium structures.

Consider a scenario where storm damage affects a roof in Liverpool, followed by water damage from a burst pipe the following year. Even though these events aren't related, having two claims close together might affect coverage availability with many carriers.

Considerations When Managing Claims History

Before submitting a claim, it may help to evaluate the full context of the situation. When deciding whether to file a claim, consider these factors that could affect insurance options:

  • The cost of damage relative to the deductible—minor damages slightly above the deductible might merit consideration for out-of-pocket payment
  • The possibility of future claims—especially relevant in Central New York where severe weather events occur
  • Current claims history within the five-year window—noting that a second claim might affect coverage availability
  • The type of damage and whether it suggests maintenance needs that could lead to future issues

For homes in our region, where winter weather increases certain risks, maintaining awareness of claims history may prove valuable when considering options for significant damage.

Considerations After Recent Claims

With a claim filed within the past five years, maintaining records of home upkeep may be helpful, especially for seasonal tasks like addressing ice dams or trimming branches near the roof. These records can show ongoing home maintenance efforts.

Some Central New York homeowners consider adjusting deductibles after a claim. This approach might help address premium adjustments while encouraging careful consideration of whether to file smaller claims in the future.

New call-to-action

How We Can Help You Understand Home Insurance Claims Decisions

Insurance claims involve many considerations regarding future coverage. With information about the typical five-year impact of claims, homeowners can consider options that align with their circumstances. Learning about how claims might affect coverage options can provide helpful context for insurance decisions.

The Horan insurance agency aims to provide information about claims history and coverage availability. We maintain relationships with multiple carriers and can share insights about how claims history typically influences coverage availability in the Central New York market.

Click the Get a Quote button below to learn about insurance options from an agency familiar with both industry patterns and local Central New York considerations.

Get a Quote

Daniel J. Middleton

Daniel is an accomplished content creator. He has been working in publishing for almost two decades. Horan Companies hired Daniel as its content manager in November 2022. The agency entrusted its messaging to him. Since then, Daniel has written insurance articles, service pages, PDF guides, and more. All in an effort to educate CNY readers. He's helping them understand the world of insurance so they can make informed decisions.