6 Key Reasons to Consider Switching Your Home Insurance Coverage

When your home insurance renewal arrives with an unexpected price increase, you might wonder about your options but feel uncertain about making changes. Many homeowners find themselves unsure about when to review their coverage and what factors to consider.

At the Horan insurance agency in Central New York, we work with multiple insurance companies to provide information about coverage options.

In this article, we'll explore the main situations that signal it's time to switch your home insurance, from premium increases and home modifications to coverage limitations and claims experiences.

Understanding When Premium Increases Warrant a Coverage Review

A rate increase at renewal time often causes homeowners to question their current coverage. Many factors affect insurance costs, including local claim patterns, carrier losses, and changes in your area's risk factors.

Let's say your premium increases substantially at renewal. Rather than immediately switching carriers, take time to understand the reasons behind the increase and compare available options. Sometimes a higher premium reflects expanded coverage or adjusted replacement costs that affect long-term coverage.

How Major Home Improvements Impact Your Insurance Requirements

Substantial changes to your home, like adding rooms or completing an addition, can affect your insurance needs. These modifications often increase your home's value and may require adjustments to your coverage limits.

For instance, if you've added a sunroom or expanded your kitchen, your current coverage might not reflect your home's new value. Similarly, converting an unfinished basement into a home theater or entertainment space increases both your home's value and potential loss exposure.

In these cases, reviewing your coverage can indicate whether your insurance aligns with your property value. If it doesn’t, it may be time to make coverage adjustments or switch carriers.

What to Consider When Starting a Home-Based Business

Insurance carriers vary significantly in their approach to home-based businesses. Some carriers maintain strict policies against any business activities, while others offer flexibility for certain types of home-based work.

Consider a scenario where you've started a small consulting business from your home office. Some carriers say no to any home business activities, while others may be more flexible with certain types of home-based work.

The type of business matters too—a home-based accounting practice presents different considerations than a small crafting business with inventory storage.

Addressing Special Coverage Requirements for Unique Items

When you acquire specialty items or collections, your current carrier might have limitations. Many carriers readily cover common valuables like jewelry, pianos, and silverware through scheduled personal property coverage. However, unique or specialized collections might require additional consideration.

For example, while one carrier might offer coverage for standard items, they may not provide coverage options for specialized collections like vintage electronics, rare books, or custom art installations. In such cases, you might consider carriers with experience insuring your specific type of valuable items.

When Adding Wood or Pellet Stoves Affects Your Insurance Coverage

Some home additions, like wood stoves or pellet stoves, may conflict with your current carrier's guidelines. These modifications can change your home's risk profile from an insurance perspective.

For instance, if you install a wood stove for supplemental heating, some carriers might decline coverage due to increased fire risk. Others might accept the modification with specific safety requirements, such as professional installation and regular maintenance. Learning about carrier requirements regarding home modifications like these can inform your planning.

Understanding Coverage Limitations and Their Impact

Coverage caps can significantly affect your insurance, particularly for specific risks. A common example involves water backup coverage for finished basements. While a $15,000 limit might seem adequate initially, it might not cover extensive damage to a fully finished lower level with expensive flooring, furniture, and electronics.

Consider a Central New York home with a finished basement used as a family room. A severe storm causes a sewer backup, damaging walls, flooring, and furniture. If repairs exceed your coverage limit, you'd need to pay the difference out of pocket. Some carriers offer higher limits for these situations.

The Role of Claims Experience in Coverage Decisions

If you've encountered challenges during a claims process—whether through communication issues or complicated procedures—it might indicate a need to explore alternatives. Different carriers handle claims differently, from the initial report to final resolution.

For example, if you filed a claim and faced unclear communication about your coverage, extensive delays, or unexpected documentation requirements, these experiences can influence your decision to explore other options.

Don't Let Insurance Review Opportunities Pass You By

You might feel stuck with your current home insurance even when situations change. The thought of reviewing policies, comparing carriers, and making changes can seem overwhelming. But overlooking key signals that suggest the need for a coverage review could leave gaps in your insurance.

We discussed several important reasons to consider reviewing your home insurance, including premium increases, home improvements, business changes, coverage limitations, and claims experiences. As an independent agency in Central New York, we can share information about various insurance options from multiple carriers.

Click the Get a Quote button below to learn about available home insurance options.