Best Auto Insurance in Central New York: 5 Carriers to Consider in 2024

Are you looking for the best auto insurance in Central New York? If so, you might be overwhelmed by the number of options available. How do you choose the right one for your situation and budget?

We understand how frustrating and confusing it can be to research insurance options. You want to protect yourself and your car from accidents, theft, and other risks, but you also don’t want to pay more than you have to. 

You want to deal with a reliable and trustworthy carrier that will treat you fairly and promptly. 

That’s why we created this article for you. We are Horan, a local and independent insurance agency that has been serving Central New York since 2009. We’ve helped thousands of customers find the best auto insurance for their needs and budget. 

In this article, we will compare five of the best auto insurance carriers in Central New York. We will look at their coverage, pricing, customer service, and other features that make them stand out from the rest.

But before we dive into the details, let’s clarify one thing: all auto insurance policies have the same basic coverage. They all cover

1. bodily injury liability, 
2. property damage liability, 
3. personal injury protection (no-fault insurance), 
4. uninsured/underinsured motorist, and,
5. collision and comprehensive when added.

The difference lies in how they present and enhance their policies.

Some carriers may offer more discounts, more flexible payment plans, more coverage options, or more perks. These are the factors that we will consider when ranking the best auto insurance in Central New York.

So, without further ado, here are the five carriers that we recommend for 2024:

Erie Insurance

Flexible Payment Plans

Erie Insurance is one of the best auto insurance carriers in Central New York for several reasons. First, they have excellent payment plans that allow you to pay monthly without any down payment or deposit. You only need to pay 1/12 of your annual premium upfront, which can save you a lot of money compared to other carriers that require 15 percent or more.

Erie Seeks to Ease the Burden of its Policyholders

Second, Erie is always looking for ways to ease the burden on their customers who face unfortunate situations that are not their fault. For example, if your car is hit by a hit-and-run driver while it is legally parked and unoccupied, Erie will only charge you $100 to fix the car, regardless of your deductible. 

This is much lower than the usual $500 or more that you would have to pay with other carriers.

Diminishing Deductible Option

Third, Erie offers diminishing deductibles on their auto policy, which stacks on top of our previous reason. This means that for every year that you are claim-free, your deductibles for comprehensive and collision coverage will drop by $100, up to a maximum of $500. 

This can save you a lot of money in the long run if you’re a safe driver. Plus, you also get benefits like enhanced towing and better rental car options if you need them.

A Preferred Carrier for CNY Body Shops

Fourth, Erie is a preferred carrier among many body shops in Central New York because they pay their claims quickly and efficiently. This means that you will get your car repaired faster and with less hassle. Some carriers may take a long time to pay or argue with the body shop over the cost of repairs, which can delay the process and frustrate you.

The Rate Protect Option

Another nice feature that Erie offers is the rate protect option for their Preferred Auto Insurance program. This means that if you have an accident, Erie will not raise your rates after the claim. This can give you added security and save you money.

Read our full review of Erie to learn more about the carrier.

NYCM Insurance

NYCM Insurance is another good choice for auto insurance in Central New York. They have two carriers: NYCM and A. Central. The latter is for those who have lower credit scores or higher claim losses. This gives you more flexibility to get a policy that suits your current situation and budget. 

NYCM has competitive rates, discounts, and coverage options. Here are some of the things that make NYCM stand out from the rest:

Up to Three Named Insureds

NYCM allows you to have up to three named insureds on a policy upon request. This is a rare feature that can save you a lot of money and hassle. 

For example, if you and your spouse have your own cars and policies, and your child wants to buy their own car, they can be added as a third named insured on your policy. 

This way, they don’t have to get their own policy, which can be very expensive for young drivers. They can also enjoy the benefits of multi-car discounts and other savings that you have on your policy. Lastly, they can build their own insurance history and credit, which can help them get better rates and discounts on their own in the future.

Good Relationship with Local Body Shops

NYCM has a good reputation among body shops in Central New York. They pay their claims quickly and fairly, and they don’t haggle with the body shop over repair costs. 

This means that you will get your car fixed faster and with less stress. Some carriers may take a long time to pay or try to lowball the body shop, which can delay the process and frustrate you.

Read our full review of NYCM to learn more about the carrier.

Travelers Insurance

Travelers Insurance is a well-known and reputable auto insurance company in Central New York. They have flexible payment plans, good claims service, and innovative features. Here are some of the things that make Travelers stand out from the rest:

A Pioneer in Auto Insurance

Travelers is a pioneer in the auto insurance industry. They were the first to offer car insurance in 1897 and the first to offer discounts for hybrid vehicles in 2006. They are always looking for ways to improve their products and services with cutting-edge technology and research.

Accessible and Convenient Online Presence

Travelers has a great online presence for managing your policy yourself. You can access your account, pay your bills, file claims, view your documents, and more on their website or mobile app. 

You can also chat with a representative, request roadside assistance, or find a repair shop near you. If you prefer to do things online, Travelers makes it easy and convenient for you.

Or if you prefer to work with an agency, like Horan, Travelers is great for that as well.

Available Specialty Insurance for Autos

Travelers offers specialty insurance for auto-related businesses and activities. For example, they offer insurance for classic cars, recreational vehicles, ridesharing, car rentals, and more. If you have a unique or special auto insurance need, Travelers may have a solution for you.

Read our full review of Travelers to learn more about the carrier.

Amica Mutual Insurance

Amica Mutual Insurance has some of the most loyal and satisfied auto insurance customers in Central New York. People who go to Amica tend to stay with them for a long time, and they rarely switch to other carriers. 

Amica has been rated the highest in customer satisfaction among auto insurers by J.D. Power for 22 years in a row. In 2023, Amica won its 60th J.D. Power award for its 2023 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, with a score of 909 on a scale of 1,000. This is 31 points higher than the industry average and six points higher than its 2022 score. 

They also have an A+ financial strength rating from A.M. Best. Here are some of the things that make Amica stand out from the rest:

Dividend Policy Option

Amica offers a dividend policy option, which means that you can get back up to 20 percent of your annual premium as a dividend at the end of the year if conditions are met. This can lower your overall cost of insurance and reward you for being a loyal customer. 

Not many carriers offer this option, and it is only available in certain states, including New York.

Wide Range of Coverage Options and Discounts

Amica has a wide range of coverage options and discounts that you can customize to fit your needs and budget. You can choose from standard coverage types, as well as optional ones like roadside assistance, glass coverage, rental reimbursement, and more. 

You can also save money by taking advantage of discounts for bundling, loyalty, safety features, good driving, etc.

Convenient Customer Service and Platinum Choice Auto

Amica has a reputation for excellent customer service and claims handling. They have 24/7 support, online and mobile access, and a network of preferred repair shops. 

They also have a Platinum Choice Auto package that gives you premium coverage and benefits, such as prestige rental, identity fraud monitoring, and full glass coverage without a deductible.

USAA

USAA is a top-rated auto insurance carrier in Central New York for military members and their families. They have exclusive eligibility requirements, but they also offer exceptional benefits, discounts, and service. 

Here are some of the things that make USAA stand out from the rest:

Some of the Lowest Premiums Around

USAA has the lowest average premiums among the major auto insurers in New York, according to The Zebra. USAA offers the cheapest rates for drivers with good credit, poor credit, good driving records, and one at-fault accident.

However, USAA is only available to military members and their families, as stated, so not everyone can access these low rates.

Wide Range of Coverage Options and Discounts

USAA offers a range of coverage options and discounts. You can choose from standard coverage types, as well as optional ones like roadside assistance and rental reimbursement. 

You can also save money by taking advantage of discounts for safe driving, defensive driving, vehicle storage, garaging on-base, etc.

Convenient Customer Service

USAA has a reputation for excellent customer service and claims handling. The company has a 4.4 out of 5 rating for customer service according to U.S. News. They have 24/7 support, online and mobile access, and a network of preferred repair shops.

You Don’t Have to Find the Best Auto Insurance or Choose the Best CNY Carrier on Your Own

We know how important it is to have reliable and affordable coverage for your car, especially in a state with harsh winters and busy roads. You deserve to have security and confidence that you are protected in any situation.

That’s why we listed five of the best auto insurance carriers in Central New York based on their coverage, pricing, customer service, and other features. We also shared some of the unique and innovative benefits that each carrier offers, such as rate protect, up to three named insureds, a dividend policy option, specialty insurance, and more.

These are the factors that can make a difference in your auto insurance experience and satisfaction.

You also need to avoid making mistakes that can leave you without adequate coverage and pile on frustration.

That’s where Horan can help you. We have the experience, knowledge, and relationships to help you compare and choose from the best auto insurance carriers in the market. We aren’t tied to any one carrier, so we can offer you unbiased and honest advice. We’re here to help you save money, time, and hassle.

Don’t settle for less than the best auto insurance in Central New York. Don’t risk paying more than you have to or getting less coverage than you need. Don’t deal with a carrier that will treat you poorly or delay your claims. Don’t miss out on the benefits and discounts that you deserve.

Let us help you find the best insurance carrier for your car in Central New York. We’re here to answer your questions, provide you with a quote, and help you with your policy. 

Click the Get a Quote button below to get started. A friendly and knowledgeable Horan agent will contact you to discuss your policy options.