Your renewal notice arrived in the mail, and the number stopped you cold. Your insurance premium jumped 22% from last year. You haven't filed a claim. You haven't added coverage. You haven't changed cars or made modifications to your home. Nothing in your life warranted this increase, yet here it is—a significantly higher bill for seemingly the exact same coverage.
This scenario plays out weekly across Central New York, leaving policyholders frustrated and confused. At the Horan insurance agency, we work with multiple carriers and see these rate increases affecting our clients regardless of their individual circumstances.
We can help you understand why carriers implement broad rate increases and explore options that may help manage your insurance costs.
In this article, we'll examine why insurance companies raise rates across their entire book of business, what drives these market-wide adjustments, and steps you can take when facing unexpected premium increases.
Market Forces Drive Rates Beyond Individual Risk
Insurance companies set your premium based on far more than your personal claims history or risk profile. While your individual circumstances matter, they represent just one small piece of a much larger financial picture.
Carriers operate by collecting premiums from thousands of policyholders and using that pool of money to pay claims. When the cost of claims rises across their entire book of business, they must collect more premium to maintain solvency. This happens even when you personally haven't contributed to those increased costs.
Disasters in Other States
Weather-related losses have created massive financial strain on insurance carriers nationwide. Hurricanes, wildfires, severe storms, and flooding events—many occurring far from Central New York—force carriers to pay billions in claims.
These catastrophic losses affect the entire insurance market, not just the regions where they occur. For a detailed explanation of how disasters in other states impact your New York rates, see our related article.
Inflation impacts everything carriers pay for claims. The cost of building materials, auto parts, medical care, and contractor labor has risen substantially. A roof replacement that cost $15,000 three years ago now runs $22,000.
Auto body repairs take longer and cost more due to complex vehicle technology and supply chain issues. Medical expenses for injury claims continue climbing. When claim costs rise, premiums must rise to match. Learn more about how inflation affects every aspect of insurance costs.
Reinsurance costs have increased dramatically. Reinsurance—the insurance that insurance companies buy to protect themselves from catastrophic losses—has become significantly more expensive. Carriers pass these increased costs to policyholders through higher premiums.
Why Rate Increases Hit Everyone Regardless of Personal Claims
Insurance companies typically cannot raise rates on a policyholder-by-policyholder basis. Instead, they file for rate increases with state insurance departments that affect broad categories of policyholders.
When a carrier determines they need more premium to cover rising claim costs, they implement a rate change across their entire book of business or large segments of it. This means your rate goes up even though you've been claim-free, because the carrier's overall loss experience requires additional premium.
Even policyholders with decades of claim-free history see substantial increases when carriers adjust their rates.
Crime rates in other parts of New York State affect your premium. If theft and vandalism claims spike in Buffalo or Rochester, carriers may implement rate increases statewide. Your Central New York location doesn't exempt you from bearing some of that cost.
Legal and regulatory changes can drive rate increases. Changes in New York State insurance regulations, court decisions affecting claim settlements, and new coverage requirements all contribute to rising costs that carriers pass along through rate adjustments.
These principles affect all lines of coverage, including why auto insurance costs so much in New York State.
What You Can Do When Facing Rate Increases
While you cannot control market-wide rate increases, you can take action to manage your insurance costs.
- Review your coverage annually with a licensed insurance professional. As your circumstances change, your coverage may need adjustment. You might carry higher limits than necessary or pay for endorsements you no longer need.
- Compare quotes from multiple carriers. As an independent agency, we work with several insurance companies. When one carrier implements significant rate increases, another carrier may offer more competitive pricing. Shopping your coverage can reveal substantial savings opportunities.
- Ask about available discounts. Bundling policies, paying in full, installing security systems, maintaining claim-free status, and other factors may qualify you for discounts that offset rate increases.
- Consider adjusting deductibles. Increasing your deductible reduces your premium. If you have sufficient emergency savings, a higher deductible may make financial sense and help offset rate increases.
- Document your property and assets. Maintaining accurate records of your coverage helps ensure you're not paying for more insurance than you need while still maintaining adequate coverage.
Moving Forward With Rate Increases
Insurance rate increases driven by market forces will likely continue as climate-related losses, inflation, and reinsurance costs remain elevated. These increases affect policyholders across all product lines—personal auto, homeowners, commercial property, and liability coverage.
We work with Central New York residents and business owners facing these rate increases every day. Our access to multiple carriers allows us to explore options when one carrier implements substantial rate adjustments. We can review your current coverage, discuss available alternatives, and help you understand the factors driving your specific rate increase.
Rate increases frustrate everyone, especially when you've done nothing to warrant higher premiums. Understanding that these increases reflect broader market forces rather than your individual circumstances doesn't make them easier to accept, but it does clarify what's happening and why.
Click the Get a Quote button below to discuss your insurance rates and explore options for managing costs while maintaining coverage appropriate for your situation.
Topics:
